A Few Things To Think About Before Using Engineered Hip or Gable Roof Trusses For Large Garages

Подробнее о видео

How To Layout And Build Garage Hip Roof Using Engineered Trusses


Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons of using roof trusses versus conventional framing (rafters) for a hip roof:

Roof Trusses (for Hip Roofs)

Pros:

Speed and Ease of Construction: Trusses are prefabricated in a factory and delivered to the site. This significantly speeds up the roofing process as they are designed to be installed quickly. Less on-site labor is required.
Cost-Effective (Often): While the upfront cost of trusses might seem higher, the reduced labor costs and faster construction often make them more economical overall, especially for larger spans like a two-car garage. Material usage can also be optimized at the factory, potentially reducing waste.
Strength and Stability: Trusses are engineered structures designed to distribute loads efficiently. They are often stronger than conventionally framed roofs, especially for larger spans, and can handle snow loads and wind uplift better.
Precise Engineering: Trusses are manufactured to exact specifications, ensuring consistency and accuracy in the roof structure. This reduces the risk of errors on-site.
Clear Spans: Trusses can span large distances without the need for interior load-bearing walls, providing more flexibility in the garage layout.

Cons:

Less Attic Space: Trusses typically don't allow for as much usable attic space as conventionally framed roofs. The web members of the truss can get in the way. If you want usable attic space, you may need to specify "attic trusses" which will increase the cost.
Limited Design Flexibility: While hip roofs themselves offer good design flexibility, the use of prefabricated trusses can limit design choices compared to stick framing. Modifications on-site are generally not recommended or even possible without engineering approval.
Transportation and Crane Costs: Large trusses require specialized transportation and often the use of a crane for lifting them into place, adding to the project cost. This is less of a concern for smaller structures.
Potential for Damage During Handling: Trusses can be damaged during transportation or installation if not handled carefully. This can compromise their structural integrity.
Difficult to Modify: Once installed, it's difficult and often costly to modify trusses if you need to change the roof's design later.

Conventional Framing (Rafters for Hip Roofs)

Pros:

More Attic Space: Conventional framing allows for more usable attic space, which can be finished for storage or even living areas.
Greater Design Flexibility: You have more freedom to customize the roof's design and make changes on-site as needed. This is especially important for complex rooflines.
Easier to Modify: It's generally easier to make changes to a conventionally framed roof after it's built.
No Crane Needed (Usually): For smaller projects, you typically don't need a crane to lift rafters into place.
Potentially Better for Very Small Roofs: For very small structures, stick framing can sometimes be quicker and cheaper than ordering custom trusses.

Cons:

More Labor Intensive: Conventional framing requires more on-site labor and carpentry skills, which can increase construction time and costs.
Slower Construction: Building a roof with rafters is a slower process than using trusses.
More Material Waste: There can be more material waste with conventional framing as cuts need to be made on-site.
Higher Skill Level Required: Conventional framing requires a higher level of carpentry skill and experience. Mistakes are more likely if the builder is inexperienced.
Can Be More Expensive for Larger Spans: For larger spans, conventional framing can be more expensive than trusses due to the increased labor and material costs.

In Summary:

For a typical two-car garage with a hip roof, roof trusses are often the preferred choice due to their speed, cost-effectiveness, and strength. However, if you need a lot of usable attic space or have a very complex roof design, conventional framing might be a better option, but it will likely cost more and take longer. Carefully consider your needs and budget before making a decision.